top of page
imagem_2026-07-02_123910144.png

STF Recognizes ITBI Immunity on Capital Contributions to Real Estate Companies

6 days ago
7 min read

In October 2026, the Brazilian Federal Supreme Court (STF) concluded its judgment of Topic 1,348 of general repercussion (RE 1,495,108/SP) and held that the ITBI (municipal real estate transfer tax) immunity on the contribution of real estate to share capital also applies to companies whose predominant activity is the purchase and sale, leasing or financial leasing of real estate. The decision is expected to put an end to a long-standing dispute that had been dragging on in the courts and that directly affected the structuring of family holding companies and real estate companies across the country.


Ultimately, the controversy stemmed from diverging interpretations of the constitutional text itself.


Among the main statements made by the Justices, we highlight the position of the Reporting Justice, Edson Fachin, whose vote prevailed and led to the following binding thesis: “The ITBI tax immunity, provided for in art. 156, § 2, I, on the paying-in of share capital through the contribution of assets and values, is unconditional and, therefore, irrespective of a predominantly real estate activity, except in cases of sham transactions or fraud against the law aimed at improperly benefiting from the tax immunity in question.”


In the Reporting Justice's view, art. 156, § 2, I, sets forth two distinct immunity scenarios: (i) the paying-in of a legal entity's share capital with assets and rights; and (ii) mergers, incorporations, spin-offs or dissolutions of legal entities. The exception regarding a predominant real estate activity, however, applies only to the second scenario. Furthermore, in line with the opinion of the Office of the Prosecutor General (PGR), the Court concluded that articles 36 and 37 of the National Tax Code (CTN) were not received by the 1988 Constitution insofar as they make the immunity on capital contributions conditional on the absence of real estate activity.


The taxpayers' victory, however, is not unrestricted. The STF expressly upheld the limit established in Topic 796, according to which the immunity does not cover the value of assets exceeding the amount effectively allocated to the paying-in of share capital. This point continues to generate heavy litigation with municipalities, especially regarding the difference between the value reported by the taxpayer in their income tax return (usually the historical, non-updated cost) and the market value of the property. At the same time, the exception for sham transactions and fraud against the law gives municipal tax authorities an explicit basis to challenge structures lacking substance, such as capital contributions followed by the immediate sale of the properties to third parties.


In any case, in practice, the outcome of the judgment significantly reduces the financial cost of setting up family holding companies and of reorganizations aimed at succession planning, paving the way for the review of transactions in which the immunity was denied solely on the grounds of a predominant real estate activity. And since the thesis was established under the general repercussion regime, all other courts must follow it, and municipalities are likely to adjust their collection practices in accordance with the Supreme Court's ruling.


Temporal modulation of the ruling's effects: what about taxpayers who have already paid ITBI?


As for the future, there is no doubt: taxpayers should no longer pay ITBI on real estate contributed to the share capital of their companies, up to the amount allocated to share capital and except in cases of sham transactions or fraud.


As for the past, since the published votes do not address the temporal modulation of the ruling's effects, we understand that taxpayers who have already paid ITBI on real estate contributed to the share capital of their companies may request a refund within 5 years from the date the tax was paid. The refund may be requested through an administrative claim filed with the municipal Finance Department or through a tax refund lawsuit (ação de repetição de indébito) brought against the municipality. It is worth noting that, under most municipal laws, the ITBI taxpayer is the acquirer (that is, the legal entity itself), which will, as a rule, be the party entitled to claim the refund.


Another detail: the refund claim only stands if the original ITBI assessment was based on the company's real estate activity. If the municipality relied on a different ground (for example, the contribution of a property whose value exceeds the company's share capital), the viability of the claim may be compromised.


However, since the decision has not yet been published and motions for clarification (embargos de declaração) may still be filed, the STF may still rule on the temporal modulation of its judgment. In that case, the right to a refund might be guaranteed only to taxpayers who were already litigating, preserving lawsuits filed up to a certain date and barring new claims. For this reason, we recommend that interested parties do not postpone their claims.


After all, can the municipality levy ITBI on the difference between the cost and the market value of the contributed property?


The discussion triggered by Topic 1,348 does not address the valuation methodology of property contributed to a company's share capital in order to determine whether or not the municipality may levy ITBI on any excess of market value over cost. On the contrary, it deals solely with the ITBI immunity in this type of transaction, regardless of the nature of the economic activity carried out by the company.


The question posed in the title of this section stems precisely from Topic 796, which ruled that the ITBI immunity cannot be extended to amounts exceeding the share capital to be paid in. In the case that gave rise to that Topic, the value of the property exceeded the subscribed capital, and the difference was recorded by the company as a capital reserve. That excess portion was, in turn, deemed subject to ITBI, since the amount exceeding the subscribed capital is not covered by the immunity.


Municipalities have mistakenly begun to interpret the outcome of that Topic as authorization to levy ITBI on any difference between the cost reported in the taxpayer's income tax return and the market value of the property at the time of the contribution, and it is this claim that has triggered heavy litigation in the state courts. After all, the “excess” referred to by the Supreme Court must be identified by comparing the value assigned by the shareholders to the property in the act of contribution with the capital subscribed in the legal entity, not by comparing the historical value with the market value of the property transferred to the company.


Nevertheless, a significant line of case law in the state courts has rejected the municipalities' reading, although the issue is not settled. Below are some of the arguments put forward by the local courts:


  • The São Paulo State Court of Appeals (TJSP), in a pro-taxpayer ruling, held that art. 23 of Law 9,249/1995 allows the share capital of legal entities to be paid in with assets and rights at the value stated in the respective individual income tax return (DIRPF) or at market value, and that the municipal tax authorities have no legitimacy to apply additional taxation to a transaction protected by law. The Goiás State Court of Appeals (TJGO), in turn, follows a similar line of reasoning;


  • The Mato Grosso do Sul State Court of Appeals (TJMS), in a ruling against the taxpayer, held that the same art. 23 of Law 9,249/1995 neither restricts the municipal taxing power nor ties the ITBI tax base to the historical value reported by the taxpayer, and that, therefore, the municipality acts correctly in recognizing the immunity only up to the amount of share capital paid in and demanding ITBI on the excess.


Complementary Law (LC) 227/2026 not only fails to resolve the impasse but makes it worse. It keeps the assessed value (valor venal) as the ITBI tax base and defines it as the value at which the property would be traded for cash under normal market conditions, granting the municipality the prerogative to estimate market value using technical criteria, provided it discloses the methodology adopted and allows for an adversarial appraisal. In doing so, the new provision strengthens the municipalities' ability to determine the market value of properties and, consequently, gives them more tools to seek taxation of the excess in capital contribution transactions.


Given the unpredictability of the municipal tax authorities' behavior regarding the levy of ITBI when a property is contributed at its historical cost, taxpayers are advised to:


1) Ensure that the value assigned to the property to be transferred to the company does not exceed the amount of subscribed capital, since any portion exceeding it (whatever the accounting classification given to that excess in the company's financial statements) will be taxed by the municipal tax authorities, as required by Topic 796;


2) Maintain consistency in the taxation of capital gains to avoid greater intrusion by the municipal tax authorities, bearing in mind that: (a) when share capital is paid in with a property at its market value, the shareholder must pay capital gains tax on the difference from the cost reported in their income tax return; (b) when share capital is paid in with a property at its cost value, taking advantage of the tax deferral granted to individuals by the aforementioned art. 23 of Law 9,249/1995, the shareholder will pay capital gains tax upon the future sale of the quotas, whereas any sale of the property itself by the company will have the gain taxed at the level of the legal entity;


3) Prepare a defense strategy to counter any additional ITBI assessment by the municipality. In line with the pro-taxpayer understanding of the state courts, the defense should emphasize that: 


  • the scope of the STF's Topic 796 is restricted to the portions exceeding the legal entity's share capital;


  • under art. 23 of Law 9,249/1995, taxpayers are guaranteed the right to contribute a property at its historical value and to defer the taxation of capital gains until the sale of the quotas, without this giving rise to a new taxable event for the municipality;


  • the taxable event for ITBI purposes is the transfer of the property from the individual to the legal entity. The increase in wealth arising from the difference between market value and cost is a separate event, which must be taxed as a capital gain of the shareholder: at the time of the contribution, if made at market value, or upon the subsequent sale of the quotas, if the shareholder opted for the deferral provided for in art. 23 of Law 9,249/1995;


  • under Topic 1,113 of the Superior Court of Justice (STJ), the value declared by the taxpayer enjoys a presumption of accuracy and may only be set aside by the municipality through a proper administrative proceeding (art. 148 of the CTN).


Recent articles

bottom of page